[Opendnssec-user] Migrating from SoftHSM 1 to 2: "ERROR: Could not get the class of object 1. Continuing."

[Stephane Bortzmeyer]

I want to migrate an old installation, which still uses SoftHSMv1.

On the new machine, I initialized SoftHSM v2:

sudo softhsm2-util --init-token --slot 0 --label OpenDNSSEC

But then migration fails:

% sudo softhsm2-migrate --db /var/lib/softhsm/slot0.db --token OpenDNSSEC
Found slot 1877891147 with matching token label.
=== User PIN (4-255 characters) ===
Please enter user PIN: ********************************
Please reenter user PIN: ********************************
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 1. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 2. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 3. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 4. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 41. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 42. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 51. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 52. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 55. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 56. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 89. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 90. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 191. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 192. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 193. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 194. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 219. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 220. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 237. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 238. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 239. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 240. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 241. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 242. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 243. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 244. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 245. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 246. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 247. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 248. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 249. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 250. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 251. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 252. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 253. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 254. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 255. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 256. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 257. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 258. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 259. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 260. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 261. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 262. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 263. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 264. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 265. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 266. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 267. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 268. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 269. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 270. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 271. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 272. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 273. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 274. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 275. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 276. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 277. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 278. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 279. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 280. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 281. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 282. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 283. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 284. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 285. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 286. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 287. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 288. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 289. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 290. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 291. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 292. Continuing.
ERROR: Unable to migrate all of the objects.

I do not find the error "Could not get the class of object" anywhere
with Google.

[Rickard Bellgrim]

It is probably something wrong in the code that reads the object class from
the SoftHSM database:
https://github.com/opendnssec/SoftHSMv2/blob/e014b86c1f3dab6f57e066171637e120de924f78/src/bin/migrate/softhsm2-migrate.cpp#L518

That SQLITE_ROW is not returned or that pValue is null / does not match the
size of CK_OBJECT_CLASS.

Could you report an issue at
https://github.com/opendnssec/SoftHSMv2/issues/new, so that we can track it
from there.

// Rickard

Post by Stephane Bortzmeyer
I want to migrate an old installation, which still uses SoftHSMv1.
sudo softhsm2-util --init-token --slot 0 --label OpenDNSSEC
% sudo softhsm2-migrate --db /var/lib/softhsm/slot0.db --token OpenDNSSEC
Found slot 1877891147 with matching token label.
=== User PIN (4-255 characters) ===
Please enter user PIN: ********************************
Please reenter user PIN: ********************************
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 1. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 2. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 3. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 4. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 41. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 42. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 51. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 52. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 55. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 56. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 89. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 90. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 191. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 192. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 193. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 194. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 219. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 220. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 237. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 238. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 239. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 240. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 241. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 242. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 243. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 244. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 245. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 246. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 247. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 248. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 249. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 250. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 251. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 252. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 253. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 254. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 255. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 256. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 257. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 258. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 259. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 260. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 261. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 262. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 263. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 264. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 265. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 266. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 267. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 268. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 269. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 270. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 271. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 272. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 273. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 274. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 275. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 276. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 277. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 278. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 279. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 280. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 281. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 282. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 283. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 284. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 285. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 286. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 287. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 288. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 289. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 290. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 291. Continuing.
ERROR: Could not get the class of object 292. Continuing.
ERROR: Unable to migrate all of the objects.
I do not find the error "Could not get the class of object" anywhere
with Google.
_______________________________________________
Opendnssec-user mailing list
https://lists.opendnssec.org/mailman/listinfo/opendnssec-user

[Stephane Bortzmeyer]

On Sun, Jan 21, 2018 at 07:27:15PM +0100,

Post by Rickard Bellgrim
Could you report an issue at
https://github.com/opendnssec/SoftHSMv2/issues/new, so that we can track it
from there.

https://github.com/opendnssec/SoftHSMv2/issues/368